>On May 5, 2001, we identified two birds as Semipalmated Plovers at Damon
>Point. After checking the field guide, based on back coloration, full black
>ring on neck, and size, we concluded that these were not the type that
>nested
>there (snowy?). We are tyros at identification and apparently were in
>error.
>
>A while back this year a report on Tweeters stated that 21 Arctic Terns were
>observed near the Everett Marina. A couple years age, a pair of Arctic
>Terns
>on the Everett Jetty was big news. There have been lots of reports of
>Swainson's Hawks on Tweeters this year. There are reports on various
>sparrow
>species which we just don't seem to see. Some thoughts come to mind:.
>
>1. Are lots of birders not as skilled as they think they are?

Yes and no. People are people-you'll get the same sort of answer no matter
with what you substitute the word birders.

>
>2. Do lots of birders see the birds they want to see?

All the time. The only question is whether they keep the doubt to
themselves, and how they present their sightings to others. I had a vagrant
eastern bird in my yard very briefly this spring. I know what it was, but I
also know that I can't provide convincing details to anyone else.

>
>3. Are lots of birders enamored with keeping lists? Is the total count
>the
>payoff? Else why include crows, starlings, etc, in lists? Has the
>mechanical process replaced simply enjoying the birds for what they are and
>blighted the ability to properly identify?

Birding can be a sport, but it's important to document the 'trash' birds
also. Bird populations and ranges are very dynamic and fun to follow,
Although admitingly more exciting than a crow, the tern are a good example
of that. However, I'm sorry that I don'y have better notes on the expansion
of crows in central Washington in the last ten years, both in numbers and
habitat. It would make a good story.
>
>4. And of course, does any field guide display many birds as we see them?

Nothing beats experience for learning how birds really look. The guides are
only that, guides. With experience you learn to put them to best use.

As a note, a person who is in birding for the sport is like any athlete-if
you aren't exercising your skills at least three times a week you're not
competitive.

My view of the world--Jerry <tangren at crcwnet.com>, Wenatchee WA

>Ed Level, Everett, WA.